Rowe Photo

Back to News Articles

REN SQUARE: Duffy's big switcheroo

Recommend Article
Total Recommendations (0)

Mayor Bob Duffy has apparently withdrawn his support from much of Renaissance Square. According to the Democrat and Chronicle's website, Duffy told D&C reporter Brian Sharp earlier today that he wants the transit center "scaled down from a block-long enclosed facility to a turn-around with a shelter."

And, according to Sharp's article, Duffy wants the site of the performing arts center cut out of the project and made available for private development.

Duffy, Deputy Mayor Patti Malgieri, and city attorney Tom Richards had been reviewing the Ren Square plan, and an announcement about the results was said to be imminent. His comments today have county, transit authority, and even some city officials in a state of high activity and some confusion. City Council had not been briefed on his decision. Duffy told the D&C's Sharp that he told County Executive Maggie Brooks about his decision on Wednesday. Ren Square officials are holding a press conference at 4 p.m. today, and Duffy will talk with media at 4:30 p.m.

UPDATE 4:30 p.m.

Ren Square officials and County Executive Maggie Brooks are shocked and confused, they said, over Mayor Bob Duffy's calls to revamp the project's design.

"I don't really know where the mayor is coming from on this project," Brooks said.

Ren Square officials held a press conference at 4 p.m. this afternoon.

Brooks pointed out that Duffy had voted to move forward with Ren Square many times over the life of the project and that 90 days ago, a city representative voted to move forward with Ren Square's final design.

Brooks and Duffy met confidentially on Ren Square on Wednesday, Brooks said, seemingly disappointed that the mayor has now apparently decided to go off-script.

Duffy's opinion doesn't change the course of the project, Brooks said.

Work is taking place on the site today, including asbestos abatement.

RBTL board chair Arnie Rothschild said he has "nothing but shock and surprise and huge disappointment" regarding the mayor's announcement.

Brooks called for Duffy to explain himself at the next meeting of the Main and Clinton Development Corp. on Thursday.

UPDATED: 5:15 p.m.

At a press conference this afternoon, a normally affable, effusive mayor appeared tense and uncomfortable while reporters grilled him on his new position on Ren Square.

Downtown has changed as Ren Square plans have dragged on, Mayor Bob Duffy said, and he's trying to protect downtown parking. Too, Duffy said he has been a longterm supporter of high-speed rail and believes it will be a reality in the region within five years.

Duffy said he did not believe that Ren Square officials could raise the necessary money for the proposed theater and that he was worried about "holes" in the middle of Main Street.

Duffy confirmed a recent meeting with County Executive Maggie Brooks and said that he told her that would not evade questions on Ren Square. A reporter asked Duffy if that meant he'd been avoiding questions about the project thus far, and the mayor seemed to backpedal, saying that he'd been clear about his position on Ren Square all along.

Duffy said that he's never felt like a true partner in the Ren Square project, despite the fact that the project is located in his domain.

Comments for "REN SQUARE: Duffy's big switcheroo " (6)

City Newspaper is not responsible for the content of these comments. City Newspaper reserves the right to remove comments at their discretion.

User Photo

Jethro Maddox said on May. 11, 2009 at 6:31pm

Perhaps the mayor needs a month or so to study up on the project, as he purports to have needed in regard to the issue of mayoral control of RCSD.

User Photo

Steve said on May. 11, 2009 at 9:09pm

Maggie is starting to remind me of Bill Johnson clinging the fast ferry. Other than a few hundred short term construction jobs, Ren Square offers very little benefit or potential use to the average taxpayer. I don't believe high speed rail is the solution to Rochester's woes either, but one battle at a time. Just stop spending our money on stupid ideas.

User Photo

Doug MIdkiff said on May. 11, 2009 at 9:25pm

What wonderful news! I am very pleased with Mayor Duffy's decision. I agree with his plan, 100%. Let the City go forward with the intermodal station at the Amtrak site, for an easy transfer between Amtrak and inter-city buses (not RTS buses). Where is the new Claude Bragdon? City planners would be well-advised to consult with Dewain Feller.

It has been a long fight. It is over, isn't it?

User Photo

Harry Davis said on May. 13, 2009 at 5:44pm

Monroe County Executive Maggie Brooks wants to destroy historic pieces of downtown Rochester, NY to make room for Renaissance Square - possibly the most ill-fated least organized project in Rochest...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xjHzgbT2Zrc

User Photo

tom said on May. 16, 2009 at 7:50am

The reason Ren Square continues to be the issue it is simply stems from the fact that the public never asked for Ren Square or anything like it. Maggie announced that she was forcing this project on the city and county.

Duffy is a very wise man to question this project, raise concerns and offer alternatives. The public was never really given that chance...and then Maggie wonders why there is little, if any, support. The support Maggie does have for the project comes from those who will benefit from the construction of the project. The rest of us will suffer because of the project when it becomes an unwelcome drag on tax payers.

The performing arts aspect of Ren Square has always been most troubling. Any new theaters built with Ren Square will simply draw interest and money away from theaters that already exist and what good would that be? Now that high speed rail is on the table, it does make sense to have an integrated transportation hub that includes local transit and the train station. That really leaves only the MCC campus and why not just rehabilitate existing space to suit that purpose.

Like Bill Johnson's fast ferry, Ren Square has had a slow leak from the beginning. I'm just hoping Ren Square idea sinks completely before the wrecking ball strikes.

User Photo

hiwayman17 said on May. 16, 2009 at 7:56am

Maggie Brooks is carrying on in the not so great tradition of George W. Bush. Get an idea, stick with it no matter what and don't listen to anyone else. That sums up the Renaissance Square project from the beginning.

This project has already wasted so much money and through all the planning and discussion, it is still a bad idea that is not and never was wanted by the majority of people in this county.

Leave A Comment

(This will not be published)

(Optional)

Respond on Your Blog

If you have a City Account you can not only post comments, but you can also respond to articles in your own City Blog. It's just another way to make your voice heard.